Kat and Mouse and Disappointment

I had one of those moments where I was lying on the floor of my room and reached out my hand touched—this:

what could I do, given that I was lying on the floor and getting up and
finding a grown-up book seemed all but impossible? Well I could read it
of course. And so I did.
It's the story of a girl whose dad gets a new job in New England, so
the family moves there to the "fancy" school, where there are mean
kids! Mean popular girls! They don't even care about science! They're
the children of senators and have names like "Chloe," and they're mean!
Really mean!
I don't know. I was really rooting for this book through the first half
(the whole thing, being a graphic novel, takes about 15 to 20 minutes
to read). I mean, who isn't against a mean girl? But there's something
uncomfortable to me in how readily we resort to the mean girl
trope: she is blonde, pretty, rich, mean. She is against the nice
girls. She has the best-looking guy, but she doesn't like him for
himself, and he, somehow, always seems to be deluded by her. He's never
seen as the real problem, more like a doofus who got taken in by the
mean girl's meanness, but who, given half a chance, would really go for
the nice girl.
The nice girl, however, in this case anyway, is not someone I feel all that much connection
to. She's just as pretty, just as far away from a person I could be or
know as the mean girl is.

all this mean girl things smacks of weird hidden misogyny to me anyway.
It's not that I don't buy the existence of mean girls. Believe me, I
know from mean girls. It's just that, I don't know: she has a
pretty name, she is pretty, she says nasty things to the nice girls,
and she ends up losing the guy. We're supposed to feel like we hate her because she's being mean, and we would like her if only she were nice, but that doesn't seem entirely accurate somehow. Instead, it's as if in constructing this whole image we're just increasing the girl-on-girl emotional violence, instead of addressing the real enemy (which is—what? I don't know, homework?)
Another part that makes me uneasy is the inevitable comeuppance, which
always seems so gleeful. That's the point where I went from rooting for
Kat and Mouse to feeling all icky: when they
catch the blackmailer (don't ask) and they use their finding to…blackmail
right back. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss. Though of course,
of course, Kat and Mouse are totally different! They're nice! They're cool! They're…part of a trend that makes me uncomfortable.
I'm not against a predictable story, at least not usually, but there's
something about the way this old familiar tune is played that seems
cynical to me.

6 thoughts on “Kat and Mouse and Disappointment

  1. What bothers me about the mean girl thing is how the mean girl is always pretty and the nice girls are always plain. It’s sort of teaching kids that you can judge a book by its cover.


  2. I think maybe you hit on something important at the end there (not that the rest of it wasn’t great)–sometimes stories are criticized for being predictible, and I’m okay with predictible, especially in books for kids. But cynical is a problem.
    I keep thinking of the movie “Lost and Dilirious” (remember when Mischa Barton was a really great actress, not merely pretty?)–a great movie about complex girl relationships, though not appropriate for young viewers. But it shows that pretty girls, mean girls, misunderstood boyfriends, they’re all complicated and so are real people. I’d like to see kids getting that message, instead of “take down the pretty mean girl” instead.


  3. I thought, these days, the nice girls always turn out to be pretty, too–just in a less obvious way, to show they don’t like themselves too much.
    You’ve read the Cynthia Voigt “Bad Girls” series? I always liked the way she handled the desires of outsiders.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.